GUEST JUDGE /BEST AD OF THE WEEK
ASIA
May 13, 2008 20:37

This week's guest judge is Tham Khai Meng, co-chairman, Asia Pacific, executive regional creative director, Ogilvy & Mather Asia Pacific, one of the world's most awarded creative directors with more than 20 years experience in advertising working in London, New York and across Asia.
Under his leadership the network has risen through the regional and global creative rankings to be crowned 'Creative Network of the Year' by Campaign Brief Asia for seven consecutive years. Khai has been named the 'Number One Creative Director' for the same period.
According to The Gunn Report, Ogilvy's massive strength lies in Asia, where the network contributes more than 40 per cent to Ogilvy Worldwide's award tally. The Asian network continues to prove its creative depth by having seven offices featured in the report's 'Most Awarded Agencies in the World' line up.
In 2005, in recognition of Khai's creative innovation to drive the Ogilvy Asia Pacific network to its present leadership position, Khai was awarded Media magazine's 'Regional Head of the Year' accolade: a first for a creative.
In the same year, Khai became the first Asian to chair the Clio Jury; he also served as the keynote speaker at the Clio Festival, Miami. New York based Advertising Age, a leading global industry commentator, named Khai 'One of the world's most influential people in the communications business'. He sits on the Board of three Temasek Holdings Companies, two Singapore Ministry Boards and the Executive MBA teaching faculty at Berlin University. Joining Ogilvy & Mather in 2000, Khai was elected to the Ogilvy & Mather Worldwide Board in 2005.
BEST TVFunny lyrics, great music, brilliant talent, authentically shot. What.
There's even a storyline! For a caffeine product, it's brave and it breaks the mould. It appeals to a younger drinker like me. The
Walk of No Shame TV spot stood heads and shoulders above the rest. Clear the shelves!
BEST PRINTI wish I liked Kit Kat
Take a break more. It has a fresh idea but it falls flat on its face, executionally. The photography is uninspiring, the art direction pedestrain and the layout, formulaic. The creatives failed to go beyond 'Here's the joke, here's the logo'. A crying shame. This brings me to my favourite ad,
X-Rayfor Road Safety Seatbelts. I've not seen an X-ray of a skeleton done like this before, so this gets my vote. Above all, it has an idea, it's well crafted and it looks dangerous. I got the message. Job done.
BEST OUTDOORThere are two contenders for the Silver. On balance,
Hubba Bubba wins. Six feet of gum is helluva gum to write home to Mom about. Holding up a purple poster with yucky bright pink bubble gum is not something you see everyday on your way to work. This poster gets my attention, which is the first job of any outdoor. It's a bubble gum ad for Pete's sake, so let's have some fun with it. Mind, the
Toyota Priusad got my full attention too. But it was let down by a poor headline, 'Respect the environment'. An alternative headline that sums up the story of how Toyota Prius can reduce carbon footprints would have saved the day (and the planet).