Seen and noted

BEST TV
Easy, Chipotle wins on execution alone. It is so beautifully done. My concern is that their 'simple life' message is starting to get a little complicated in this new film. Runner up is Smirnoff - the best of an average bunch.

BEST PRINT
Tricky to find anything that really stood out here but, if pinned against the wall and threatened with anal rape, I would grudgingly go with VW to look like I meant it and Divinopolis because there has to be a runner up.

BEST OUTDOOR
Certainly not the best FT ad since the Campaign began but it is at least simple and communicates with economy which is more than can be said of the others. Runner up, Cadbury Bourneville as silly as it is familiar.

BEST INTERACTIVE
Again, slim pickings here. Hollywood and Vines is at least innovative - if really rather dull. Runner up, a shameless plug for Samsung Galaxy Note 111.



This week's guest judge is Justin Tindall, group executive creative director at Leo Burnett, London.

Justin graduated from Goldsmiths College in 1989 with a degree in Fine Art alongside the likes of Damien Hirst and Tracey Emin.

Attracted by the 'Ideas' side of advertising his first agency role came in 1991 at FCA - arguably the UK's first genuinely integrated agency where his ground-breaking campaign for The Wales Tourist Board caught the Attention of DDB London.

7 years at DDB London saw Justin become Head of Art, Creative Director, a member of the Exec Board and one of the most awarded Creatives in the World. His work for Volkswagen, Lurpak, Marmite, The Guardian and Harvey Nichols winning the top honours at all the World's major Advertising Festivals including D&AD, Cannes Lions, BTAA Arrows, The One Show and The Clios.

2006 saw Justin move to The Red Brick Road as Creative Partner where he oversaw multi-award winning campaigns for Heineken, Olympus, Thinkbox and Magners Cider.

In January 2011 Justin joined Leo Burnett London as Group Executive Creative Director.